Citation, Documentation of Sources

Q. Hello! I am providing guidance to art history students on creating bibliography and note entries and have a few questions that I’m not sure of the answer to: (1) How would one style the name Hans Holbein the Younger in a bibliography entry? (2) When a work of art doesn’t have a title and is simply a description, I assume it would be in sentence case and not italicized, but is this correct? For instance, this glass ribbed bowl at the Met. (3) I assume for guesstimate dates “ca.” would be preferred, but would “18th century” or “Edo period” be acceptable?

Q. I’m wondering how you would treat an online report from an NGO or watchdog organization? What type of source is it parallel to? I’m asking to instruct my students for the author-date format. There is no specific author, just the organization. There is a specific date of publication, not just a year. This is the specific source, but there are others that are similar: https://humena.org/political-satire-in-egypt-a-peaceful-protest-against-repression/. Thank you.

Q. Why do you use a colon to separate page numbers in a journal article citation but a comma to separate page numbers in most everything else? It seems completely nonsensical.

Q. A paper includes the following references:

Tawiah, Vincent, Ernest Gyapong, and Muhammad Usman. 2024. “Returnee Directors and Green Innovation.” Journal of Business Research 174 (March): 114369.

Tawiah, Vincent, Ernest Gyapong, and Yan Wang. 2024. “Does Board Ethnic Diversity Affect IFRS Disclosures?” Journal of Accounting Literature, ahead of print, September 24.

Tawiah, Vincent, Reon Matemane, Babajide Oyewo, and Tesfaye T. Lemma. 2024. “Saving the Environment with Indigenous Directors: Evidence from Africa.” Business Strategy and the Environment 33 (3): 2445–61.

Tawiah, Vincent, Abdulrasheed Zakari, and Rafael Alvarado. 2024. “Effect of Corruption on Green Growth.” Environment, Development and Sustainability 26 (4): 10429–59.

Should I still cite the first two references in the text as first author, second author, et al. YEAR (e.g., Tawiah, Gyapong, et al. 2024), even though only one author is not mentioned and so “et al.” doesn’t seem appropriate?

Q. When citing an endnote, should the page number be the page the note callout appears on or the page where the endnote is at the end of the book (24n5 vs. 385n5)?

Q. I’m in the middle of working with a client on a white paper that has citations to articles found on government agency websites (e.g., Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institutes of Health, Office of Disease Prevention). The writing is completed, we’re in the layout/​production stage, and while checking links and confirming URLs in the endnotes, we’re finding that articles and pages that had been referenced in our endnotes have now been removed from the government websites in accordance with the administration’s recent orders. How do we reference reports and articles that are significant but have been removed?

Q. I am wondering how best to cite, within one chapter of a multiauthor book, other chapters from the same volume. I am accustomed to simply adding “(see chapter X)” to the text, but one author is pushing back and wants to see them in the reference list. We are using author-date style.

Q. CMOS 13.128 shows how to use author-date citations in a footnote, but what about an informational footnote like, “The history of exclusion of Chinese people in the United States has been highly researched. To begin, see . . .”? Should the parentheses around the citations be removed, as in “To begin, see Chan 1991, Lee 2003, and Kurashige 2016”? Otherwise, it might seem as though the citations are substantiating the statement, rather than being offered as suggested reading.

Q. I find ISBNs extremely useful when trying to locate copies of books of interest, especially when searching for secondhand copies of out-of-print books, for requesting books on interlibrary loan, and for disambiguating common names or titles. I’m writing a literature review in the form of an annotated bibliography and would like to include ISBNs in the entries for those books that have them, as a convenience and finding aid for readers. I can’t find any guidance for inclusion of ISBNs in Chicago-style footnotes or bibliography entries, even as an optional item. Can you provide a recommended template or example of placement and formatting?

Q. Hello, Chicago doesn’t seem to have an example of how to cite a contribution to a new edition of a book. Should the edition number follow a period or comma in the reference list entry below? Though my example is in Chicago 17 style, the question is still relevant for Chicago 18 style, so I would appreciate your guidance. Thanks!

Rothbard, Murray N. 2006. “The Libertarian Heritage: The American Revolution and Classical Liberalism.” In For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto, 1–23. 2nd ed. Auburn, AL: Ludwig von Mises Institute.