Subscribe to The Chicago Manual of Style Online
Quotations and Dialogue
Q. I am in the awkward situation of trying to cite an excerpted book review that appears on the dust jacket of an updated edition of said monograph. While it seems technically correct to cite the name of the reviewer, the book being reviewed and its author, the title of the original source of the review, “quoted in” Book Being Reviewed, 2d ed. (publication information), jacket; this also strikes me as convoluted and vaguely ridiculous. Finding the source of the original review would provide a way out, I know, but I’d rather not sift through several months worth of copies of the Daily Telegraph (c. 1965).
A. I know it’s a drag, but for credibility’s sake you must either cite accurately your source within a source or dig up the original and cite that. The idea is to give the reader enough information to track down the source.