Citation, Documentation of Sources

Q. Concerning the author-date system of references, we use in-text citations and many times in-text citations end up in footnotes. Some authors will write “See Author1 2011, 123–34, and Author2 2000, and Author3 2004.” Others would write “See Author1 (2011, 123–34), and Author2 (2000), and Author3 (2004).” Which is correct?

A. Both styles are popular and conform to Chicago style, though the first form, if used at all, should normally be reserved for notes that include source citations only, without additional commentary. For notes that consist of a mix of sources and commentary, the second form is best. Please see the examples throughout CMOS 13.115–28. Semicolons work well in place of and.

[This answer relies on the 18th edition of CMOS (2024) unless otherwise noted.]